Denver's Best Homes

Marla Doughty
Marla Doughty 720.454.5432

DENVER HOME BUYER’S GUIDE · STEP 8 OF 10

Appraisal, title and homeowner’s insurance

Three things happen in the weeks after your inspection: the lender confirms the value, the title company confirms the seller can sell, and you line up insurance.

What if the appraisal is low?

While you’re packing, three pieces of work are going on behind the scenes. You don’t have to manage them, but you should understand them, because any one can change your plans. I keep an eye on all three and tell you the moment something needs your attention.

The appraisal

Your lender hires an independent appraiser to estimate what the home is worth. The lender will only lend against that value, so the appraisal protects both of you from overpaying. Once it’s in, your file goes to underwriting for final loan approval, and you’ll receive your final loan terms.

Four ways an appraisal can come in

At the contract price

The most common result. If the home was priced in line with recent sales, the appraiser usually agrees.

Above the contract price

Good news. You’re walking into the home with equity on day one.

Subject to repairs

The appraiser notes something the lender needs fixed before it will fund the loan, such as a safety issue. We ask the seller to handle it before closing.

Below the contract price

Not unusual in a changing market, or when recent sales were in better condition. See your options below.

If the appraisal comes in low

You have options, and the right one depends on how big the gap is and how much you want the house.

  1. 1Ask the seller to lower the price. Often to the appraised value. Sellers know the next buyer’s appraisal may come in low too.
  2. 2Bring more cash to closing. The lender lends on the appraised value, so you’d cover the gap yourself.
  3. 3Meet in the middle. A combination of a price reduction and extra cash from you is common.
  4. 4Terminate the contract. Unless you waived it, the Colorado contract lets you walk away by your appraisal deadline and keep your earnest money.
Modern kitchen in a Denver-area home

Title work

The title company researches the property’s ownership history to confirm the seller actually owns it and that any liens, loans or judgments are found and paid off at closing. You’ll receive a title commitment early on. I review it with you, along with any HOA documents, so nothing surprises you later.

You’ll also receive an owner’s title insurance policy after closing. It protects you if an ownership problem turns up later that the search missed. In the Denver area the seller usually pays for it, but it’s negotiable and spelled out in your contract.

Homeowner’s insurance in Colorado

Your lender requires insurance in place before closing. Start shopping during your inspection period, not the week before closing, because Colorado insurance has gotten more complicated.

Hail is the big one

Colorado sees some of the most hail damage in the country. Ask how the policy covers the roof. Some pay full replacement cost, others only actual cash value on older roofs, which can leave you paying much of a new roof yourself.

Check the claims history

A CLUE report shows insurance claims on the property from the last seven years. Several past claims can mean higher premiums. It costs little or nothing and is worth pulling early.

Wildfire areas

Homes in the foothills and on the western edge of the metro can be harder and more expensive to insure. If that’s where you’re looking, get quotes before you make an offer.

Frequently asked questions

Who pays for the appraisal?

The buyer, usually through the lender. Some lenders collect it upfront and some add it to your closing costs.

What happens if the appraisal is low and the seller won’t budge?

You can bring extra cash to cover the gap or terminate by your appraisal deadline. Some buyers add an appraisal gap clause to their offer in competitive situations, agreeing up front to cover a set amount. I’ll explain the risk before you decide.

Do I need title insurance?

Your lender requires a lender’s policy. The owner’s policy protects you, and in the Denver area the seller usually pays for it. I recommend it on every purchase.

When do I need homeowner’s insurance?

Before closing. Your lender will need proof of coverage, so get quotes during your inspection period.

← Step 7: Negotiate inspection itemsAll 10 stepsStep 9: Schedule your move →
Marla Doughty, Broker Associate at Compass

Questions about your appraisal or title?

I’ll walk you through the report or commitment and tell you what, if anything, needs action.

Book a call720.454.5432

General information, not legal, insurance or lending advice. Your contract’s deadlines and terms control. Last reviewed September 2026.